Average NFL player salaryUS pet insurance policies in force
It appears that somewhere between 2005 and 2022, Americans developed a profound conviction that the financial wellbeing of professional athletes who throw footballs for a living is mysteriously linked to their willingness to insure their dachshunds against urinary tract infections. One might expect these two datasets to have met once at a party and politely ignored each other forever. Instead they have moved in perfect lockstep, like dancers who have never met but share an inexplicable choreographer.
The explanation is almost certainly that both trends ride the back of a much larger force: the steady enrichment of a specific American middle-to-upper class cohort during these years, interrupted only briefly by the 2008 financial crisis. Pet insurance adoption exploded as veterinary costs climbed faster than inflation—a 2005 pet owner simply couldn't have afforded the kind of procedures available by 2020—while NFL salaries rose because the league's broadcast rights kept selling for incomprehensibly larger sums (a $40 billion contract in 2022 versus roughly $3.7 billion in 2006). Both trends represent the same underlying phenomenon: a widening pool of Americans wealthy enough to treat both professional sports as premium entertainment and pet healthcare as a budget line item rather than an emergency gamble. The number of policies in force grew from roughly 100,000 in 2005 to nearly 3.3 million by 2022, which is to say the entire industry expanded by about 3,200 percent while your favorite linebacker's salary went from reasonably comfortable to actually absurd.
What we are looking at is not a cause or a mysterious alignment, but rather two different bells attached to the same invisible rope—one labeled 'disposable income' and one labeled 'why not.' The real question isn't why these datasets correlate so perfectly, but why we keep expecting unrelated human behaviors to move independently when nearly everything in an economy is ultimately connected to nearly everything else. We are pattern-seeking creatures trying to make sense of a world that mostly just makes sense in one direction: upward, until it doesn't. Both NFL salaries and pet insurance policies tell the same story about money. They just tell it in very different accents.
As an Amazon Associate, getspurious.com earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more.
Want to learn more about why correlations like “Average NFL player salary” vs “US pet insurance policies in force” don't prove causation? Read our guide to statistical thinking.